Sortuvocracy and the HST : protecting the Government from the will of the People.

The process of implementing the HST in BC continues to illuminate my long standing arguments about why people have lost faith in our system of government.

I have already written about the democraticness of introducing the new tax weeks after campaigning on a platform of no new taxes, but the Recall and Initiatives Act is an even better example of the safeguards in place to shield governments from having to represent the people.

 The Zalmer’s initiative to repeal the HST under the Act is a noble gesture that is doomed to failure. Not because there aren’t enough people who passionately hate the new tax. Not because the drive won’t be well-organized. Not because of a lack of volunteers. The initiative will fail because even if the canvassers somehow collect enough signatures under the incredibly stringent guidelines, the government DOESN’T HAVE TO DO ANYTHING ABOUT IT! That’s right. Even if every single person in BC signed the petition, the government would not have to repeal the hated new tax! The Recall and Initiatives Act is specially formulated to ensure that, ultimately, the ruling government can not be forced to represent its people.

How’s that for democracy? The funny thing is that the ACT is a groundbreaking and revolutionary tool of modern democracy. Before its inception in 1994 we didn’t even have a pretend process for people led initiatives! Now at least we have that.

I just don’t get why we cling–like a monkey to her dead baby–to the label of Democracy, when we so clearly don’t have one. Maybe a true democratic system isn’t currently possible, but who decided that all you have to do is hold the odd election in order to use the title? Now anyone who has an election gets to call itself a Democracy. It’s ludicrous. Pericles and Cleisthenes would be all hella trippin on these noobs if they were up in these times.

I see almost no connection between a democracy, in which citizens debate issues and make decisions, and our current system, in which decisions are made by one party or the other. The best we can hope for is a change of oligarchies every few years. Are we cool with that?

And don’t tell me that adding the qualifier “representative” before democracy makes it OK. That’s an even bigger insult, as it implies, well, representation. “Representation” means doing something on behalf of someone, not to someone. The HST debacle illustrates this beautifully. The vast majority of citizens clearly oppose the HST. So who is being represented in its implementation?

I’m not calling for true democracy over night. I’m just saying let’s call a spade a spade.

Either change the system or change the name.



Filed under Canadian politics, Random, yet deep, thoughts

5 responses to “Sortuvocracy and the HST : protecting the Government from the will of the People.

  1. Calzone

    Will you sign the petiion?

  2. Jason Scott

    Yes, I’ll probably sign it, simply to say, “the way this was done is not OK.”

    I’m not so much against the HST as I am against having a governmental system with no connection to the people. As long as we accept this system, governments will find ways to get more money from us. If it’s not HST it will be an increase of other taxes: MSP premiums, fees, gas taxes, EI, parking meters, tolls, etc. They’re all taxes going to one level of government or the other.

    MPs, MLAs, and even some municipal politicians make a lot of money and have fat pensions. Those things don’t pay for themselves.

  3. WHS

    You are “the government” now. Are you willing to give “the people” some of your decision making power? What would you do differently?

  4. Pingback: 2010: HST+Facebook=The End of Sortuvocracy? | Jason Scott: confessions of a self hating politician

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s